Erik L. C.

After being with my sweetie, Monica, for over a year and a half, I was ready to pop the question. We had been talking about rings, what shape stone she liked... finally, I was pretty sure I knew what she wanted, but how to ask? I decided that I would propose on her birthday in March--what better way to remember when we got engaged?! I really wanted to make the occasion special, so I arranged to have a birthday party, inviting various friends and family, but unbeknown to Monica, I told everyone that this would be a surprise engagement party! It was about two months in the making--getting the ring ready, getting the invites out, making sure everyone kept quiet. My plan was working out perfectly.
One day before the "big day," I received an e-mail from a co-worker which was copied to Monica about some dinner plans. The communication was very matter-of-fact, but I wanted to let my co-worker know about the big day coming up that weekend. So I shared a bit of the big-secret-proposal plan. Now, here's the
rub: I didn't hit "reply," but I didn't realize that.
I hit "reply ALL."
Later that day, Monica and I were talking on the phone. I brought up the subject of the dinner plans, and Monica, somewhat mysteriously, somewhat innocently, replied, "I didn't get any e-mail." So I pressed her again, insisting that I sent her some e-mail about dinner plans. She then repeats shyly, "I didn't get any e-mail." Silence on the phone. It starts to occur to me, like that feeling when you're outside on a cold and icy day that you're about to slip on the ice and you know you will fall and hurt yourself, but you can't stop falling. That's how it felt. I'm thinking to myself, "oh NO!" The well-kept secret I've been trying to preserve for the past two months--all for naught! I was so upset that I started to cry! I called out on the phone, "YOU DIDN'T GET ANY E-MAIL!!" And Monica echoed, "No. I didn't get any e-mail." I think I repeated myself a few times.
So..... the next day, Monica's birthday, arrives. At least in my faux pas I didn't reveal exactly WHEN I would be proposing--just that it would be coming. I was at least successful in diverting her away from my apartment where the party was to be. I drove her down to the waterfront (I live by the Hudson) and asked if she'd like to go for a walk along the water. I knew she knew this was it, but I didn't care. I was going to make this as special as I could, given the circumstances. We walked hand in hand and eventually got to a nice place to sit. I asked my sweetie to have a seat and I held her hands and looked in her eyes. I got down on one knee, looked up at her, and declared my love for her. I told her that she meant the world to me and that I wanted to spend the rest of my life with her. I got out the ring and received a big smile.
We laughed. We cried. She said yes. We hugged tightly against the March wind. We then both agreed it was too cold to stay outside and got back in the car.
We drove back to my place where everyone laid in wait.
A shout of "surprise," and "congratulations," and the party was on! At least I was successful in surprising Monica with the attendees. Our wedding is coming up this June. I do intend to surprise Monica again, but I'll try to leave the e-mail out of it!
Cantor Erik L. Contzius
New Rochelle, New York